Making
yogurt is a tradition in my family, but making dairy-free yogurt has been a
trial and error process. My grandmother has dabbled in the kitchen making
yogurt out of soymilk and occasionally mixing in a little almond milk (although
I must warn you making homemade yogurt from commercial almond milk is quite
literally impossible). For me, coconut milk yogurt is the holy grail of
dairy-free yogurts. However, as I have
previously blogged about, the price of commercially processed coconut yogurt is
enough to make the best yogurt taste sour! Although, I love the store-bought
stuff but I hate exposing my little one to all that added sugar in it as well (the
typical store bought yogurt has about as much added sugar as 2 tablespoons of
frosting).
My
go-to recipe is a recipe I found over 4 years ago that I’ve been tweaking ever
since and will likely continue to tweak as my yogurt making progresses. I have
only ever used a "yogurt maker" that is a warming plate with a lid
that is specifically designed to keep yogurt at the correct temperature for
fermentation (I have the Euro Cuisine Digital Automatic Yogurt Maker YMX650
). Therefore if you have any
questions about making yogurt in a crockpot, dehydrator I’m not the best
resource for a good response. But I’ll work hard to find good links to these
methods and update this blog post accordingly.
The
biggest downside to this recipe is that coconut milk does not naturally contain
any calcium and I love having the addition of calcium in commercially prepared
coconut yogurt. I’ve started to play around with adding calcium in the form of
calcium to the yogurt. I’m starting small and I’ll gradually increase the
amount as time goes on and see if it affects the consistency at all. So if
calcium is a concern for you check back periodically to see how the recipe
evolves. I’ll also keep you posted via facebook as I tweak the recipe.
Oh!
Before I forget, as far as add-in's to the yogurt go, after it's all fermented
and chilled I like to mix in fresh fruit, mango chutney is amazing in this
yogurt, homemade pineapple jam, apricot preserves, the list goes on! You're
only limited to your imagination! It also makes a great add-in
to smoothies.
Three 14.5 ounce cans coconut milk
1/4
teaspoon non-dairy yogurt starter/probiotic (I use Custom Probiotics Formula 2 - the
company can add in additional strains and customize the blend for you as well)
2
tablespoons agave nectar
1 –
1 ½ tablespoons unflavored vegan gelatin
¾ teaspoon calcium citrate powder, divided
1)
With boiling water, sterilize your yogurt containers, mixing
spoons and other utensils.
Note: Depending on what type of
dishwasher you have you might be able to forgo this step and sterilize in your
dishwasher. Mine has a high-temperature wash setting as well as a sanitizing
rinse setting. I use both of these settings in combination with a heated dry to
sterilize my equipment. This takes more time and water but I like using this
option on the weekends I can get everything sanitized while I’m eating
breakfast then just reach in the dishwasher and grab the tools I need. This
will keep bad bacteria from competing with the good yogurt bacteria
2) Pour coconut milk
into a medium saucepan and bring to a low boil, you’re shooting for 180oF
so you’ll need to use a food grade thermometer to check the temperature and
make sure it doesn’t go over 180oF. Once milk has reached 180oF
remove it from the heat. And whisk in the gelatin and then agave nectar until
thoroughly combined.
Note: You must use some type of sugar in order for your
yogurt to culture properly. This is probably the #1 question I get. Without
sugar the culture has nothing to eat and cannot grow. Non-nutritive sweeteners
like xylitol and stevia will not culture your yogurt. Using granulated sugar or
agave nectar is your best option. The bacteria will eat most of the sugar and
very little will be present in your end product.
3) Find a cool spot in
your kitchen and allow milk to cool to 95oF, checking occasionally
with a food grade thermometer (make sure you sterilize the thermometer after
each check). This is a long process and can take up to an hour, sometimes
longer so this might be a good time to pull up a little light reading or get
some chores done around the house.
4) Once milk has
cooled whisk culture into the milk and continue to whisk until thoroughly combined,
at least 60-90 seconds.
5) Pour cultured milk
into your yogurt maker jars. Cover and ferment at for 9-12 hours. The longer
you ferment the yogurt the more the bacteria will consume the sugar within it
therefore longer fermentation times yield a sourer yogurt.
6) Once yogurt has
been fermented remove the jars from the yogurt maker and sprinkle 1/8 teaspoon
of calcium citrate powder into each jar and stir to combine. Cover jars with
lids and refrigerate for at least 6 hours, I prefer overnight and sometimes up
to 24 hours. If you peak in on
your yogurt and it appears to have separated now worries, just give it a quick
stir and you’ll be back on track!